Gas chromatography (GC) vs High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC)
- GC stands for Gas chromatography (Refer: Gas Chromatography (GC)) and HPLC stands for High-Performance Liquid Chromatography.
- Both are separation techniques that have added massive popularity in industrial laboratories.
Brief difference between HPLC vs GC enlisted as below,
Application:
- HPLC (High-Performance Liquid Chromatography) has applications in pharmaceuticals, foods, life sciences and polymers
- Gas Chromatography (GC) has imperative applications in the environmental air monitoring, petroleum and petrochemical industry, & flavours and fragrances.
Mobile phase:
- High-Performances Liquid Chromatography as name suggested liquid used as mobile phase whereas GC (Gas chromatography) operated by gas as the carrier.
- Liquids are mostly mixtures of solvents and buffers of compatible polarities. In gas chromatography, the mobile phase is a high purity gas carrier.
Operating temperature:
- Operating temperature of HPLC is mostly carried out at ambient temperatures (around 25°C) while Gas Chromatography separations are operated at elevated temperatures (around 250°C) which can be maintained at a constant value (isothermal) or variable as decided by the temperature program on the requirement of analytical methods.
- Newer packings & external column oven have extended temperature limits of HPLC at some point for operation as well.
- Temperature programmed gas chromatography (TPGC) is the procedure of cumulative the column temperature during a run in GC.
Separation of Compounds:
- Gas chromatography separations are mainly carried out on compounds that are volatilities and remain stable at high temperatures that may be up to a few hundred in molecular weights.
- HPLC can be used in compounds having higher molecular weights ranging from a few hundred to several million for large polymers and biomolecules. They are mainly operated at room temperature as on elevated temperatures compounds have a tendency to degrade.
Column used in HPLC and GC & Column Packings:
- HPLC (High Performance Liquid Chromatography) normally uses columns that are shorter with wider diameters in comparison to GC columns.
- Because in HPLC Mobile phase having the liquid which have higher viscosity, which leads to creating more back pressure.
- In GC columns are much longer and narrower. Enlarged column length advances resolution between closely spaced peaks..
- C8 & C18 Column packings used in HPLC.
- GC Chromatography uses packed and capillary columns which have a higher permeability of solid supports than liquids.
- The retention of analyte HPLC columns mainly depends on polarity differences or molecular sizes.
- GC Chromatography separations are built on differences in volatilities of sample.
Related: Difference between HPLC and UPLC, Handling of HPLC and GC Columns
Detector used in GC and HPLC:
- Type of HPLC Detectors: are UV-Vis, RI, photodiode array detectors (PDA), conductivity and laser detection.
- GC Detectors are FID, NPD and FPD.
- Mass spectrometry detectors common to both like LCMS and GCMS.
Cost of operation:
- HPLC solvents are more costly in contrast to gases used for GC Chromatography analysis.
- Maintenance charge of GC and HPLC depends on use, but due to high use and requirement of solvent to operate HPLC costly than GC.
- Tandem techniques like LC-MS-MS and GC-MS-MS have prolonged the limits of detection to new frontiers of detection and automation in machines has also donated to increased laboratory uses.
Read More:
- Difference Between Isocratic and Gradient Elution
- Calibration of HPLC Gas Chromatography Columns
- Why is 70% the More Effective Concentration of Isopropyl Alcohol for Disinfection?
- Difference between Incidence and Deviation
- Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC)
- Paper Chromatography
- Thin Layer Chromatography
- Difference Between Thin Layer and Paper Chromatography
- Type of Glass container used in Pharmaceuticals
- Fume Hood
- Type of HPLC Column
- Type of Capsules
- Advantages and Disadvantages of Capsules
- Type of HPLC Detectors
- Difference between HPLC and UPLC
More Topic: